more hp theroys SPOILER WARNING

okay so i'm just gonna post theroys on here as i think of more lol

Assuming that Dumbledore knew about the unbreakable vow AND about Malfoy's mission then here's sumthin to ponder

Why did Dumbledore try to talk Malfoy out of killing him? He does always try to find the good in people and I'm sure he knew that Malfoy wasn't TERRIBLE and that he could LOVE. But, knowing that, he would also know that Snape would have to kill him. So maybe there's a very specific reason Snape killed Dumbles. Also when Dumbledore was "pleading" maybe he was pleading with Snape to kill him. For some reason or another. I dunno. Chew on that for a while


here's another

Okay so trewlany is trying to warn Dumbledore about somehting ot do with the tower if i am much mistaken right? My bro has the book so i can't check facts. But Dumbledore refuses to listen to her. Did Trewlany make a real prediction? If so, why does she remember it? Does she always remember them adn pretend not to. Moreover, why didn't Dumbledore listen? We all know she's a little nutso but Dumbledore WOULD ahve taken into consideration is she was THAT freaked and stuff. Plus Dumbledore always had that special way of believeing when the time was right. But instead he just acted like she was her nutso self again. Not very Dumbledorish. So we should be asking ourselves.... did Dumbledore know of the plan the whole time? Why didn't Harry tell him what happened with Trewlany right away! You would think. But instead Dumbledore took his mind off of Malfoy and the vanishing closet adn teh Room of Requirement. Why? I think Dumbledore knew the plan the ENTIRE time!!!!! I think dumbles can predict the future or SOMETHIN